Welcome to Zclub - Australia's Largest Nissan Z/G Community
Register for FREE to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing topics, give reputation to other members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. This message will be removed once you have signed in.


auto/manual

15 posts in this topic

Posted · Report post

i know this has been asked before.Im looking at buying 370 roadster but wife wants me to by auto so she can drive it.Ive never had a sports car auto(or one that she can drive).Will i regrete it?For those who have had an auto for a while are you regreting not getting a manual

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Posted · Report post

Hey Elvis, I (we) got an auto for the same reason. So wifey could drive it. Two years down the track ... She still hasn't driven it. But, I'm loving the auto. Great fun when you slap it in manual mode and rev it out and shift with the paddles. And for days when I wanna chill I just leave it drive and cruise away..  Best of both worlds IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

that would piss me off  if she doesnt drive it.I like driving manuals.what are the gear changers like(delay)?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Not too bad, slight lag ,but generally pretty good. Go to a dealer and take one for test drive.. See what ya think. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Hey elvis, how did you go, get the roadster? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I'm almost there,I've driven a few auto/man and I am taking my time.I have decided on 2011/12 Gray.This will be a weekend car only so mine not in a hurry,just waiting for the right car.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I recently got a 2013 roadster auto.  Great car and very happy with both the auto and manual feel. Coming out of a manual wrx the auto wins hands down. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I bought an auto for similar reasons, we (the wife & I) regularly do a 6 hour each way drive to central west NSW to check on her ageing parents.

Really handy to have another driver to do the stints where the cops are usually hiding lol.

She cant drive a manual & its the only time she drives the car, but still worth it imo.

I'm in my 50's & its the first auto i've ever owned, i've owned & built some fairly high performance manual vehicles over the years so this was quite a step.

Overall i'm pretty happy with it, I do however only drive with the paddles in manual mode.

So I haven't fully let go yet.

After 2 years of practice with the paddles I feel i know the trans pretty well, mind you my 370gt has the 5at not the 7 in the Z, that said, they feel much the same to drive.

It is a little laggy in some circumstances, generally down shifting in the lower rev range.

I find the harder I push it, the more positive & faster the changes are, especially on the down shifts.

Once you get to know the trans you can work around its weaker shifting areas to improve the experience.

Being a Modder I am about to fit a Shift kit & a remote cooler I bought a while back, which i'm hoping will tidy up a couple of those weaker shift points & generally improve the feel.

So yeah, I'm pretty happy with it.

Cheers.

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Thanks for the reply,tell me what you mean with the shift kit(I assume they already have a manualize kit in it)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Ok, first let me just say I'm definitely no expert on Automatic Transmissions, as I stated earlier, this is my first Auto equipt personal car.

I have however been around Auto's quite a bit & built cars for friends/customers previously fitted with Auto's, so i think I have a fairly decent understanding.

Firstly I'm not aware of an off the shelf kit available for the 7at, any decent transmission specialist should be able to make one up though. Fortunately they are available for the 5at which is what I have.

So what does it do? Well its really just a way to modify the behaviour of your trans.

You firstly need to understand that the Auto box, like a lot of components on the Z are set up from the factory with a compromise between performance & comfort to cater for the big variety of owners.

There are also other things built into the equation such as drive line preservation etc,etc.

The trans is designed to shift smoothly, reliably & predictably to suit most Z buyers & not put to much strain on the tailshaft uni's, differential & axles & not kick out to much under full throttle changes in the wet etc.

What a shift kit does, is it pushes the line across to the sporty side at the sacrifice of the comfort side.

Shifts under heavy throttle applications become much faster & firmer, but they should not become harsher.

In other words they should not overly Jar the driveline.

One of the biggest noticeable areas of change is in the lower gears.

First to second & second to third will be noticeably faster as they are the softest changes on a stock box, done by the factory that way for the reasons outlined above.

After shift kitting (depending on your tyres) you should be able to get a good chirp from full throttle changes in this area, which is just highlighting the more positive engagement of the gears.

In very basic terms, when an auto changes gears, for example changing up from second to third, when the shift happens, third is engaged before second is released, when second is released that is the moment when the change happens. The friction plates in the trans control this & just like in a manual trans, the application of the clutches determines how the shift feels.

The length of time for this operation to happen determines the speed of the shift & the amount of heat generated by the friction plates.

This is a must under high horsepower applications as well as other modifications, such as more aggressive friction material on the plates, more plates where they can be fitted, & machining out the friction drums to accommodate extra plates.

All of this stuff is on the mechanical side of the trans, but there is also tweaks that can be applied the electronic control too.

Back to just a shift kit though, some people such as myself love them & others not so much.

It really all depends on what exactly the individual wants from their car.

I hope that was some help to you & apologies for rambling on a bit.

Cheers, Trevor.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited) · Report post

Others have done it - see 2012 post below

I would be concerned about the load on the bands and durability

As a motor sport oriented guy I really hate conventional auto's with torque converters (with 1 exception, the ZF transmission) - for a sports car like the Z I would always go for the manual.

My daily drive is a VAG with the DSG auto - dual clutch - absolutely love it - no torque converter, dual clutches (real clutches), lightening fast changes, but also seamlessly smooth and non eventful during the daily grind.

Dual clutchs seem to be a Euro thing, the Japanese have not embraced dual clutches at all, instead they prefer CVT (continually variable), but every CVT owner I've spoken to says they won't buy one again.

 

 

Edited by MartinZ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Well explained,I love rambling

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I would be concerned about the load on the bands and durability

Nothing to be concerned about, at stock, or mildly upgraded power levels, the shift kit will actually make life easier for the transmission.

A more positive engagement will reduce the heat generated & dumped into the oil.

Wack on a decent cooler & you should get plenty of fast laps without overheating it.

Increasing the power put through it without further modifications will however reduce its lifespan.

Just like with a manual transmission, is you feed more power into it you will quickly find the weakest link, usually the clutch

In an NA application imo its all positive, the extra force is transferred further down the driveline, you may see slightly earlier wear on the drive shaft & axle uni's/cv's, well worth the trade off imo.

Big power increases from forced induction is where the Auto is gonna cost you some coin, where as the manual trans seems to be good to go, other than the previously mentioned mandatory clutch upgrade.

Cheers Guys,

Trevor.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

after looking for over a year finally found the right car,the wife is extremely happy it's an auto.look forward to catching up and talking about type of mods 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I absolutely love this car,just done over a thousand km on the great alpine rd this weekend.The power is pretty good ,actually surprised me.When is the next catchup.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now





  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Unsure if bad coil / cylinder not firing?
      By brendontharp · Posted
      Hi Guys,   ive had this sound for a while . car hasnt been driven in years basically . i took all sparks out and replaced them but did find a fair amount of oil in spark/cyl 6 which i believe is just a VQ thing ill do the valve cover just trying to find the cause of the noise / issue first. . ive cleaned it all up and sound is still there. could it be a bad coil or has anyone else come into this?    video-1591410978.mp4 video-1591410984.mp4
    • Best project car: Regular 370Z or NISMO?
      By Ralph Kneale · Posted
      Hi, 370Cal. Thanks for replying to my post. I can see it'll be pricey to turn my 370z into an M2 beater, but I think it's worth it. I like the looks, old-school layout, and classic Japanese tuner's dream aura. I think it'll be a blast to get it up to speed. As for return on investment, I'm not concerned about that. I just need to turn-over my cars every four years to continue to benefit from depreciation at tax time. I might keep this one, after four years, and write something else off. Cheers. Hi, Marsh. Thanks for the specific details regarding tuning. I like your approach: everything other than the engine first. That's always been mine too. The first things I would do are to tighten and tie-down the body, which I know isn't light. I also like what you said about a mechanical LSD. Those things are the best additions to a car's performance parts, in most cases. It's good to hear your car's on rails. I have struggled to find anything by car reviewers that goes into the inherent balance of the car. I just want to avoid  a car that understeers. For example, an Audi RS3, which has loads of power, a short wheel base, and isn't very heavy (although also not light). It understeers like a boat, and that handling flaw just can't be fully corrected by street legal suspension changes.  As far as the engine is concerned, I'd be very interested to see what the 370z can do short of forced induction. If I go down that route, I'll get a supercharger because I want to retain sharp throttle response. I checked-out the link you provided; it looks like your car goes where it's pointed. Cheers, Ralph 
    • Best project car: Regular 370Z or NISMO?
      By Marsh · Posted
      Hi Ralph im also 45 YO. And own the very car you describe, For me it’s a road registered track only car and sometimes it gets taken out for the odd cruise (twice in a year). I bought a used 2014 Non Nismo 370z Manual and did the following mods, the intention was to always have this as a track toy.  Oil cooler Z1- This needs to be your first Mod  New Hardrace bushes and rear arms throughout the car. stillen exhaust front upper control arms (SPL)  good set of 2 piece disks and race pads- brakes are really good for about 6 -7 Hard laps  Then you have to back off for 1- I may get brake ducting, I see no need for an upgrade here. MCA Red coil overs - best Mod ever I can turn them down and they are very comfy.  white line front sway Bar  standard rear sway bar  Standard subframe and diff bushes ( I need to do the diff ones)  1 race seat 😀 1 professional race level alignment and corner balance  Nt01 semi slick 275 40 18 all round  car has a basic tune to enable left foot braking and maybe get it a little more responsive -uprev Nismo body kit for the looks - 😎 the car is absolutely on Rails And turn In is Porsche like. In the correct hands will Keep up with a hi end sports Car ( Not on the straights however, but Its not drag racing! )    Things I’d do to it now? 
      half cage (For my well-being)  Mechanical LSD As the VLSD doesn’t like getting hot and I have to change fluids every track day to keep it working. a few instructors have jumped in with me and they have been surprised on the cars composure and balance and those guys get to see a lot of cars. https://youtu.be/olkAcVSDwYs Im after something Lighter and more track only for my next car and am contemplating selling the Z but I would do so with a heavy heart, Maybe I can convince the Wife to keep it for her Daily....    All the best       
    • Apple CarPlay
      By papajhotel · Posted
      Hi, has anybody tried using Naviplus  to update the stock head unit? Looks like a tidy solution.
    • Best project car: Regular 370Z or NISMO?
      By 370Cal · Posted
      Hey Ralph, Depending on what sort of power plant you left the clio in (in terms of mods and such) The nismo will be a far greater contender with the right mods attached. Depending on your overall budget for the car, off the top of my head. Everyones go-to mods are: Intake, hfc, cbe, tune, coilovers will set you a good 7k give or take on install costs. And given the right tuner you’ll see 240kw atrw. If you want to go turbo or supercharger. You’ll need deeper pockets unfortunately. Some turbo kits from the states are an easy 15k without clutch, flywheel and some without fuel pump and injectors. And obviously a tune on top. Then you add your coilovers and exhaust to that equation too. I’d personally set aside a potential 80k including cost of the car if you were looking for a daily driven track car. And i wouldn’t really expect a great return on investment at the end of the 4 years regardless of the mods. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk